A Report by the
Palestinian Centre for Human Rights on the Closure Imposed by Israel on the
Gaza Strip
“1)
All people have the right of self-determination.
By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and
freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development.
“2)
All peoples may, for their own ends, freely dispose of their natural wealth and
resources without prejudice to any obligations arising out of international
economic co-operation, based upon the principle of mutual benefit, and
international law. In no case may a people be deprived of its own means of
subsistence.”
Article
1, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1996)
“No
one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his property.”
Article
17, Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)
“1)
Everyone lawfully within the territory of a State shall, within that territory,
have the right to liberty of movement and freedom to choose his residence.
“2)
Everyone shall be free to leave any country, including his own.”
Article
12, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
“No
protected person may be punished for an offence he or she has not personally
committed. Collective penalties and
likewise all measures of intimidation or of terrorism are prohibited.
Pillage is prohibited. Reprisals
against protected persons and their property are prohibited.”
Article
33, The Fourth Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons
in Time of War (1949)
“Each
High Contracting Party shall allow the free passage of all consignments of
medical and hospital stores and objects necessary for religious worship intended
only for civilians of another High Contracting Party, even if the latter is its
adversary. It shall likewise permit
the free passage of all consignments of essential foodstuffs, clothing and
tonics intended for children under fifteen, expectant mothers and maternity
cases.”
Article
23, The
Fourth Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time
of War (1949)
“1)
The States Parties to the present Covenant recognize the right to work, which
includes the right of every one to the opportunity to gain his living by work
which he freely chooses or accepts, and will take appropriate steps to safeguard
this right.”
Article
6, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
“1)
The States Parties to the present Covenant recognize the right of everyone to
the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health.
“2)
The steps to be taken by the States Parties to the present Covenant to achieve
the full realization of this right shall include: …
d-
the creation of conditions which would assure to all medical service and
medical attention in the event of sickness.”
Article
12, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
“1)
The States Parties to the present Covenant recognize the right of everyone to
education. They agree that
education shall be directed to the full development of the human personality and
the sense of its dignity, and shall strengthen the respect for human rights and
fundamental freedoms.”
Article
13, International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
This
is the 29th special update in a series published by the Palestinian
Centre for Human Rights on the total closure imposed by the Israeli occupation
forces on the Gaza Strip. This
update documents the impact of closure. The
Israeli occupation authorities have continued to impose a total siege on the
occupied Palestinian territories for the 12th consecutive week as
part of a collective punishment policy adopted by the Israeli occupation
authorities against the Palestinian people in violation of international
conventions, particularly the Fourth Geneva Convention Relative to the
Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War.
In
the beginning of this special update, the recent impact of the external siege
imposed on the Gaza Strip and its citizens is examined.
Then, the effects of the internal siege imposed on Palestinian cities and
the consequent humanitarian, economic and social suffering of Palestinian
civilians will be surveyed.
1. Impact of the External Siege by the Israeli Occupation Authorities on the Gaza Strip
The
Israeli occupation authorities have continued to impose a total siege on the
Gaza Strip. As a result,
Palestinian suffering and the deterioration of living and daily conditions have
continued. Despite claims from the
Israeli occupation authorities that they took new measures to ease the siege,
the reality has been quite the opposite. Although
they reopened Al-Mentar (Karni) Outlet on November 19, 2000, they have continued
restrictions on free passage of goods from and into the Gaza Strip, allowing the
entry of limited amounts of goods under strict procedures.
They have also hindered the export of Palestinian products, allowing the
transport of only some of these products.
Furthermore,
the Israeli occupation authorities have continued to impose tough restrictions
on free movement of persons between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, and
between the Gaza Strip and Israel as well as the outside world.
Consequently, more than 24,000 Palestinian laborers from the Gaza Strip
have been denied access to their work places inside the Green Line.
Additionally, hundreds of Gazan students have been deprived of their
right of education in Palestinian universities in the West Bank.
Families of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails have also been
prevented from visiting their sons, and hundreds of patients have been prevented
from receiving adequate medical attention outside the Gaza Strip.
Following are the latest developing effects of the Israeli siege on the economic and social conditions of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip:
1) Continued Restrictions on Commercial Transactions
The
Israeli Occupation Authorities have continued to impose tough restrictions on
commercial transactions through Al-Mentar (Karni) Outlet, the only outlet that
was reopened by the Israeli occupation authorities on November 19, 2000, under
tough restrictions and strict measures. The Israeli occupation authorities have
continued to impose restrictions on free passage of goods from and into the Gaza
Strip, through the Outlet. In
addition, they have prevented the movement of Palestinian traders and
businessmen from the Gaza Strip to the West Bank and Israel.
UNRWA
accused Israel of hindering the access of its supplies for about 2.5 months into
the Gaza Strip. Israeli security procedures and the imposition of hefty taxes
on these supplies proved to be serious burdens.
The UN General Commissioner Peter Johansen stated that UNRWA was facing a
serious situation due to a shortage of basic materials, such as foodstuffs,
medicines and construction materials to repair houses of Palestinian refugees
destroyed by Israeli shelling.
2) Continued Denial of Palestinian Laborers’ Access to Their Work Places
The
Israeli occupation authorities have continued to prevent the access of more than
120,000 Palestinian laborers to their work places in Israel, including 24,000
organized laborers from the Gaza Strip and 16,000 from the West Bank who used to
work in Israel (through the Bureau of Labor) before the current siege.
Of the 120,000 laborers, 80,000 are unorganized laborers. They have all been denied access to their work places in
Israel.
In
addition, thousands of laborers have lost their work places in the local market
because of the paralysis that has gripped Palestinian economic sectors under the
current siege. This has led to a significant increase in the unemployment
percentage. Unemployment has reached 50 percent, and poverty among Palestinians
has significantly increased. The
Office of the UN Special Coordinator expected that the level of poverty would
increase to 31.8 percent by the end of December if the siege continued.
The poverty percentage in the occupied Palestinian territories was 21.1
percent before the current siege. In
light of this, it is clear that the percentage of poverty among Palestinians
could increase 10.7 percent in only three months.
This is a significant increase that proves the serious deterioration of
Palestinian economic and living conditions as a result of arbitrary Israeli
measures. It also sets the stage
for further deterioration of these conditions if these measures, through which
Israel seeks to strangle the Palestinian people by starving them and destroying
their economic resources, continue.
On
December 13, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces handed about 3,000 work permits
for Palestinian laborers from the Gaza Strip to the Palestinian Ministry of
Labor, under new conditions related to the age of laborers.
These conditions required that laborers be over age 37 in order to be
able to work in Israel. They also
provided that laborers be clear of security precedents according to claims made
by the Israeli occupation authorities.
Official
sources of the Palestinian Ministry of Labor stated that in the morning of
December 14, 2000, 43 Palestinian laborers from the Gaza Strip, bearing new
permits, went to their work places in Israel through Beit Hanoun (Erez)
Checkpoint. On the following day,
50 workers went to their work places in Israel.
3) Further Deterioration of the Agricultural Sector
The
Palestinian agricultural sector has been one of the most damaged sectors of the
Palestinian economy under the current siege imposed on the occupied Palestinian
territories. Losses in this sector have been manifested in an inability to
market agricultural products due to the siege imposed by the Israeli occupation
authorities, especially as the current siege has coincided with the season for
exporting strawberries, olives and flowers.
Furthermore, the Israeli occupation forces swept large areas of
agricultural land and destroyed agricultural facilities, equipment and wells
owned by Palestinian farmers.
In
this context, on December 8, 2000, the Israeli occupation authorities prevented
the passage of approximately seven trucks loaded with strawberries through Al-Mentar
(Karni) Outlet. These strawberries
were ready for export to European markets.
The cargo of these trucks was estimated at dozens of tons with a value of
US$50,000. This measure had no
purpose except to cause large losses to Palestinian farmers, especially as the
failure to move the strawberries in due time (requiring them to be loaded on
trucks for long periods of time) damages the agricultural product and spoils it
for export. As a result,
Palestinian farmers are forced to sell this product at low prices.
Strawberries
are one of the most important agricultural products in the Gaza Strip.
The area of agricultural land planted with strawberries is estimated at
1,700 donums (1 donum=1,000 square meters or .24 acres), centered in the north
of the Gaza Strip. More than 700
Palestinian farmers work in this field of agriculture.
Palestinian official sources estimate the production of strawberries for
this year at about 5,000 tons, including 2,000 tons for export to outside
markets, especially Europe, and 3,000 for local consumption.
The same sources warned of the seriousness of continued measures taken by
the Israeli occupation forces against the marketing of strawberries.
Palestinian strawberry farmers have already suffered large losses under
the current siege, including crossing closings. The siege and closings have left these farmers unable to
export strawberries to Europe, the major consumer of this product at this time
of the year.
4) Further Deterioration of the Industrial Sector
Losses
in the industrial sector increase day by day as many Palestinian factories have
stopped operating for lack of necessary raw materials on which they depend.
Under the current siege imposed by the Israeli occupation authorities, 75
percent of these raw materials are imported from Israel or from other countries
through Israeli harbors. Thousands
of Palestinian laborers have lost their work places in industrial factories as
these factories have stopped operating due to the lack of raw materials.
This is yet another factor leading to an increase in the level of
Palestinian unemployment.
Under
the continued blatant aggression launched by the Israeli occupation forces on
the Palestinian people, these forces have destroyed a number of Palestinian
factories through artillery shelling and heavy machine gunning.
This is a significant part of the illegal Israeli policy of collective
punishment against the Palestinian people and their property.
Losses
to the Palestinian industrial sector can mainly be attributed to the following:
(a)
Continued prevention of the entry of raw materials.
(b)
Continued prevention of the export of industrial products to outside
markets.
(c)
The inability of Palestinian laborers to reach their work places due to
the siege imposed on Palestinian cities and villages.
(d)
The complete cessation in the normal movement and transactions of
internal trade between Palestinian cities due to the siege.
(e)
The destruction of a number of Palestinian factories with artillery
shells and heavy machine guns.
Reports by the
Palestinian Ministry of Industry stated that the decline in the Palestinian
industrial sector between September 28, 2000 and December 12, 2000 was estimated
at 80 percent.
5) Construction
Construction
came to a standstill since the siege on the Gaza Strip was imposed about 2.5
months ago. The closing of Sofa Crossing, the crossing through which
cement aggregate enters the Gaza Strip, was the major factor in this
construction stoppage.
On November 28, 2000, the Israeli
occupation authorities allowed the entry of cement used in construction into the
Gaza Strip, after its entry into the Gaza Strip had previously been completely
prevented. Since then, however, the
Israeli occupation forces have allowed the entry of only 650-700 tons of cement
daily; that is 19,500-21,000 tons monthly, through Al-Mentar (Karni) Outlet.
Israeli trucks unload their cargo of cement at the Outlet and then
Palestinian trucks transfer it into the Gaza Strip.
Palestinian official sources stated that 75,000 tons of cement used to
enter the Gaza Strip monthly before the current siege.
The amount the Israeli occupation forces have allowed to enter the Gaza
Strip, 19,500-21,000 tons, is limited and not enough to meet the cement needs of
the Gaza Strip.
Palestinian
official sources stated that more recently – the past two weeks – the daily
entry of 750-800 tons of cement was allowed into the Gaza Strip.
On December 12, 2000, the Israeli occupation authorities allowed the
entry of 1,000 tons of cement into the Gaza Strip.
Yet they have continued to prevent the entry of cement aggregate.
In a few days, cement will be without value if the Israeli occupation
authorities continue to prevent the entry of cement aggregate and other basic
construction materials.
As
a result, infrastructure development projects in the Gaza Strip, mainly financed
by donor countries, have stopped due to the lack of necessary construction
materials. Major projects are Gaza
Harbor and an electricity generation station.
Projects of municipalities have also stopped, although limited amounts of
cement were allowed entry in the past two weeks.
The stoppage is because the Israeli occupation authorities have continued
to prevent the entry of other materials, such as “basecourse” and asphalt
which used to enter the Gaza Strip through Sofa Crossing.
Consequently, hundreds of Palestinian laborers who used to work in these
projects have been unable to work.
In
addition, the blatant Israeli aggression and shelling of Palestinian residential
neighborhoods by missiles and heavy machine guns caused the destruction of
hundreds of housing units as well as portions of social services, police
stations and infrastructure networks.1
6) Further Deterioration of the Health Situation
The
health situation has deteriorated as the Israeli aggression against the
Palestinian people continued. Since the outbreak of clashes on September 29, 2000, the
number of Palestinians killed by the Israeli occupation forces and settlers has
increased to more than 280, with more than 9,000 wounded by live ammunition and
rubber-coated metal bullets, many of whom were left with permanent handicaps.
This is a result of excessive use of force by the Israeli occupation
forces directed at Palestinians rising up against the Israeli occupation and the
aggressive actions of the occupation forces.
In light of daily illegal actions committed by the Israeli occupation
forces against defenseless Palestinian civilians, health conditions in the
occupied Palestinian territories are deteriorating.
The
Israeli occupation authorities have continued to obstruct the immediate access
of medical supplies provided by Arab donors, Arab countries and other countries
friendly to the Palestinian people. In
addition, these forces have obstructed the transfer of the wounded to
neighboring Arab countries and their return to the occupied Palestinian
territories after receiving medical treatment abroad.
7) Continued Deprivation of the Right of Education
Since
the Israeli occupation forces imposed the current siege on the occupied
Palestinian territories, Gazan students have not been able to attend classes at
their universities in the West Bank, in violation of their right of education.
Additionally, Gazan students who have been in the West Bank have not been
able to visit their families in the Gaza Strip.
8) Violation of the Right to Travel
Israeli measures aimed at suffocating the
Palestinian people have also violated the right of Palestinian civilians to free
travel. Since the outbreak of Al-Aqsa
Intifada on September 29, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces have closed Gaza
International Airport several times for no clear reasons.
On December 1, 2000, the Israeli occupation authorities partially
reopened the Airport, but under new work conditions and time limits, after three
consecutive weeks of closure. The
new conditions imposed by the Israeli occupation authorities on the operation of
Gaza International Airport are as follows:
1)
The operation of the Airport shall be limited to six hours, from 9:00 to
15:00 local time.
2)
Privileges granted to Palestinian VIPs of categories A and B shall be
canceled.
3)
Privileges granted to staff of Palestinian planes shall be canceled.
4)
Security checking of travelers through the Airport shall be continued at
Rafah Border Crossing. These
travelers shall be transported to the Crossing by special vehicles that shall be
escorted by tanks of the Israel occupation forces instead of Israeli security
personnel. PCHR’s field officer
in Rafah reported that the Israeli occupation forces demolished a part of the
Airport fence in order to facilitate the entry and exit of tanks.
There is little benefit in reopening Gaza
International Airport so long as the Israeli occupation forces continue to close
the main road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip and divide the
country into several parts by establishing roadblocks.
Under the internal siege imposed on Palestinian cities and villages, a
Palestinian citizen faces difficulties on the way to the Airport. Citizens often
need more than three hours to cross all the roadblocks of the Israeli occupation
forces. The airport flight
timetable is adapted to the times the main road between the north and the south
of the Gaza Strip is opened by the Israeli occupation forces. This airport flight timetable is set only for the next 24
hours.
9) Violation of the Right to Worship Freely
The total siege imposed by the Israeli
occupation authorities on the occupied Palestinian territories has deprived
thousands of Palestinians in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip from making the
minor pilgrimage to Mecca, Saudi Arabia, which is usually desired in the month
of Ramadan. Like other Muslims,
thousands of Palestinians are eager to make the minor pilgrimage to Mecca, but
the strict closure and siege imposed on Palestinian cities, including closing
the main and branch roads as well as closing border crossings, have severely
hindered many Palestinians in traveling to Saudi Arabia for the minor
pilgrimage.
In this context, an official of a travel
and tourism office in Gaza City stated that the annual number of Palestinians
going through the office for the minor pilgrimage was 300-400.
As a result of measures taken by the Israeli occupation authorities, this
number has decreased this year to only 50.
The number has decreased this year because of the continued aggression
launched by the Israeli occupation forces against the Palestinian people.
This has forced many Palestinians who wanted to make the minor pilgrimage
to cancel their bookings. These
Palestinians are now worrying for their families or spending the costs of the
trip for the benefit of their families due to the current difficult living
conditions.
Under
the total strict siege on the occupied Palestinian territories, Palestinians
from the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, both Muslims and Christians, have been
prevented from visiting the holy sites in Jerusalem.
The Israeli occupation authorities have prevented the access of
Palestinian Muslims in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip to the sacred city for
prayers in the month of Ramadan. These authorities have also continued to close
the Ibrahimi Mosque in Hebron, preventing Muslims from praying there, in
violation of the right to worship freely.
2. Impact of the Internal Siege on Palestinian Cities
In
addition to closing border crossings and Gaza International Airport and
isolating the occupied Palestinian territories from the outside world, the
Israeli occupation authorities have imposed internal closures on Palestinian
cities and villages. On November
14, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces closed Salah El-Din Street (the main
road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip), near the junctions leading
to Gush Qatif settlement block and Kfar Darom and Morag settlements.
They also closed the entrance of the road branching from Salah El-Din
Street leading to Kissufim Crossing in the east, preventing the movement of
Palestinian citizens in both directions. The
Israeli occupation forces have continued to reinforce their presence along Salah
El-Din Street at the main junctions and at the entrances to Palestinian cities
in the Gaza Strip.
Palestinian
citizens face difficulties in moving between the southern area of the Gaza Strip
(the cities of Rafah and Khan Yunis) and the middle and northern areas.
Palestinian citizens have been forced to resort to a bypass road that
passes near the eastern border of Kfar Darom settlement where Israeli occupation
forces are positioned in order to obstruct the movement of Palestinian citizens.
Crossing this road can take more than two hours of waiting at the
roadblock of the Israeli occupation forces.
Even this bypass road is sometimes closed by the Israeli occupation
forces, absolutely halting the movement of Palestinian citizens between the
southern and northern areas of the Gaza Strip.
As a result, the Gaza Strip has been transmuted into areas isolated from
one another.
On
November 19, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces reopened Salah El-Din Street,
but these forces continue to put roadblocks on the road, obstructing the
movement of Palestinian transportation. On
the morning of November 20, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces re-closed the
road less than 24 hours after it was reopened.
These forces also closed the bypass road which Palestinian citizens
resort to in case Salah El-Din Street is closed.
With the two roads closed, the south of the Gaza Strip was isolated from
the north. This tight closure lasted for several days during which
Palestinian employees and university students from the southern area of the Gaza
Strip who went to their work places and universities in Gaza City could not come
return home and were trapped in Gaza City.
The
southern area of the Gaza Strip largely depends on Gaza City, which plays a
major role in providing health, educational and commercial services and other
daily life assistance. The strict
three-day closure obstructed the movement of Palestinian citizens, and the
access of medical and technical staff to work places in the European hospital in
the south of the Gaza Strip. Physicians from the southern area of the Gaza Strip who work
in hospitals in Gaza City were not able to reach their work places.
On
November 23, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces partially reopened the bypass
road that crosses the road branching from Salah El-Din Street leading to
Kissufim Crossing in the east (Abu El-Ajin road).
These forces started to allow Palestinian citizens to move through this
road during the periods of 10:00-12:00 and 16:00-18:00 local time.
PCHR’s field officers reported that the road witnessed traffic jams
during the hours when Palestinian citizens were allowed to move under strict and
humiliating security procedures. Salah
El-Din Street, the main road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip was
closed until December 5, 2000.
The
Siege on Al-Mawasi (Agricultural) Area
The
Israeli occupation forces have been imposing a strict siege on Al-Mawasi
(agricultural) area, which is under the control of these forces, in Rafah and
Khan Yunis. These forces have
completely closed Al-Tuffah roadblock. They
have separated the people of the city and refugee camp of Khan Yunis from Al-Mawasi
area by putting in place cement blocks. Palestinian
civilians undergo humiliating checking procedures by the Israeli occupation
forces at the mentioned roadblock. These
forces prevent the passage of cars, so Palestinian civilians, including
children, women and the elderly, are forced to walk more than three kilometers
from the roadblock to reach their houses. PCHR’s
field officer in Khan Yunis reported that Jerar Al-Qedwa school, the only school
in Al-Mawasi area of Khan Yunis, in which more than 600 elementary and
preparatory stage pupils have classes, has been closed by the Israeli occupation
forces. Consequently, these pupils
have been deprived of their right of education.
The suffering of residents of this area has been increasing and their
living and health conditions increasingly deteriorating.
In addition, settlers have continued to attack Palestinian civilians in
order to confiscate their land. Settlers
aim to harass and intimidate Palestinians to such an extent that they feel
forced to leave the area, allowing the settlers to take over the area.
In
another escalatory step, on December 2, 2000, the Israeli occupation authorities
closed six branch roads connecting Al-Mawasi area and its farms with the coastal
road at the Khan Yunis seashore. These
forces carried out the job with barbwire and cement blocks.
As a result, Palestinian farmers have not been able to reach their farms
and lands.
Residents
of Al-Mawasi area became completely isolated from the cities of Khan Yunis and
Rafah due to measures taken by the Israeli occupation forces.
Israeli occupation soldiers positioned at Al-Tuffah roadblock, separating
Al-Mawasi area from the city of Khan Yunis, and those positioned at Tal
Al-Sultan roadblock, separating Al-Mawasi area from the city of Rafah, willfully
provoke residents of Al-Mawasi area and prevent them from carrying on their
regular lives. They prevent the
passage of cars, so Palestinian civilians are forced to walk long distances to
cross the area of the roadblock and reach their houses.
Students and employees of the area are also usually provoked by the
Israeli occupation forces which disturbs regular access to schools and jobs.
Furthermore,
residents of Al-Mawasi area have been prevented from taking any foodstuffs into
the area, a measure that threatens their lives.
Additionally, Palestinian farmers of Al-Mawasi area have been prevented
from marketing their agricultural products in local and outside markets.
Most residents of Al-Mawasi area work in agriculture due to the fertility
of the land there.
In
another unjustified escalation, on December 4, 2000, Israeli occupation soldiers
positioned at Al-Tuffah roadblock opened fire at teachers of Jerar Al-Qedwa
school in Al-Mawasi area of Khan Yunis without advance warning, preventing
access to the school. This was one day after allowing the resumption of study at
Jerar Al-Qedwa school, which had been closed for two weeks after the outbreak of
clashes, in a blatant violation of the right of Palestinian civilians to an
education.
On
December 8, 2000, Israeli occupation forces prevented the entry and exit of Al-Mawasi
area residents into and out of the area for two days.
Even those traveling on foot were prevented from moving under the strict
siege imposed on the whole area. This
was another threat to the safety and security of residents of the area.
A
summary of the most significant aspects of the suffering of residents of Al-Mawasi
area under the strict siege imposed on the area for more than two months is
provided below.
¨
The prevention of the entry of
foodstuffs into the area.
¨
The difficulty faced by patients
in getting to hospitals and clinics and the prevention of the entry of
ambulances into the area to evacuate patients.
¨
The difficulty faced by citizens
in getting to their work places because of roadblocks established by the Israeli
occupation forces.
¨
Difficulties faced by students in
attending their classes at schools and universities.
¨
Damage to agricultural products
due to preventing Al-Mawasi farmers from marketing their agricultural products
in local and external markets.
¨
Restricting the work of fishermen
and preventing them from sailing.
The
policy of internal closure and siege imposed by the Israeli occupation
authorities on Palestinian cities and villages constitutes a blatant violation
of the economic, social and cultural rights of Palestinian civilians, whose
living conditions are increasingly deteriorating as a result.
Following are the most significant consequences of the internal siege on
Palestinian civilians:
(a) The Violation of the Right to Free Movement
Due
to the restrictions imposed by the Israeli occupation forces on the movement of
Palestinian citizens, manifested in closing Salah El-Din Street (the main road
between the north and south of the Gaza Strip), Palestinian citizens who wish to
go to Gaza City are forced to travel by taxis at 9:00 in the morning, in order
for these taxis to get their turn on the road when it opens at 10:00 in the
morning. When taxis reach the
junction, Palestinian citizens get out of taxis at the roadblock of the Israeli
occupation forces and walk 2-3 kilometers to reach the other side of the
junction. Then they take other
taxis to travel to Gaza City. The
same happens on the way back in the evening.
Under these circumstances, Palestinian citizens cannot fully carry out
their objectives in traveling to Gaza City as they spend much of their time in
travelling back and forth, Many cannot even reach their work places on time.
Furthermore,
PCHR’s field officer in the middle area of the Gaza Strip, where the mentioned
roadblock of the Israeli occupation forces is located, reported that Palestinian
civilians who are forced to travel along this bypass road are required to wait
for long periods of time and are humiliated by provocative measures taken by the
Israeli occupation forces. Israeli
occupation forces positioned at the mentioned road often use tear gas against
Palestinian civilians on the road. Clearly
what was a simple trip now poses dangers to the safety of Palestinian civilians
traveling along the road.
Moreover,
the internal siege that cuts the Gaza Strip into separate parts has resulted in
large losses to Palestinian farmers and traders as a result of difficulties they
face in transporting and marketing their products.
In addition, taxi drivers also suffer large losses as hundreds of taxis
stopped working under the internal siege imposed on Palestinian cities and
villages.
(b) The Violation of the Right to Receive Medical Treatment and Care
The
internal siege imposed on Palestinian cities and villages restricts the movement
of ambulances and physicians between Palestinian cities and villages.
It also obstructs the access of patients and medical staff to hospitals.
These restrictions exceeded all limits when the Israeli occupation forces
closed Salah El-Din Street (the main road between the north and south of the
Gaza Strip) on November 20, 2000. As
a result of closure of this road and other branch roads leading to the south,
the cities of Rafah and Khan Yunis became completely isolated from Gaza City.
They were consequently deprived of medical supplies.
Additionally, physicians from Gaza City could not reach their work places
in the two cities. Ambulances transferring the wounded from the southern area
were prevented from reaching hospitals in Gaza City. This measure posed threats to the lives and safety of the
wounded. Serious cases are usually
transferred to hospitals in Gaza City because of the lack of necessary medical
equipment in the hospitals of the southern area of the Gaza Strip.
(c) The Violation of the Right to Education
Isolating
the south of the Gaza Strip from its north upset the Palestinian educational
process as many teachers at schools in the southern area are from the middle
area and Gaza City. These teachers could not reach their schools in the southern
area. In this context, UNRWA tried
to avoid such disturbances through substituting teachers in these areas so that
each teacher could teach at schools in his or her area of residence.
This program could partially solve the problem in some subjects, but the
problem remained in other subjects.
In
addition, university students from the southern area could not reach their
universities in Gaza City. These students constitute 50 percent of the student body at
these universities. This resulted
in disturbing the academic process in the Gaza Strip. The number of university students from the southern area who
study at universities in Gaza City is estimated at about 14,000 students.
These students study at the Islamic University, Al-Azhar University, the
Open University and the College of Education in Gaza City.
In
this regard, about 400 female students from the southern area of the Gaza Strip
were forced to spend a night at the campus of the Islamic University after they
could not go back to their houses in the southern area because Salah El-Din
Street (the main road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip) and all
branch and bypass roads leading to the southern area were closed on November 20,
2000. As a result, university students from the southern area who
went to their university in Gaza City in the morning of that day could not go
back to their houses and were forced to stay at the Islamic University or with
relatives.
Some
study rooms in the Islamic University became temporary shelters in which the 400
female university students from the southern area were forced to spend the
night. That evening, the Israeli
occupation forces shelled the Gaza Strip with missiles.
Electricity was cut in Gaza City and sounds of explosions were heard near
the Islamic University. These
students felt a great deal of tension, some of them fainted and others were
terrified and worried for their classmates.
The
Islamic University was forced to open branches in the southern area of the Gaza
Strip in order to enable its students in the southern area to proceed with their
classes. Other universities
organized compensatory programs to enable students of the southern area to
recover what they lost in classes.
PCHR’s
field officers reported that the Islamic University established an emergency
committee mandated to open branches for the university in the southern area to
conclude the current semester and to maintain the academic process.
This emergency committee, in coordination with some official and local
parties, was able to provide 15 centers in Rafah and Khan Yunis for teaching
students of the southern area. Study
in these centers started on December 2, 2000, and about 2,500 students – the
number of students from the southern area attending the Islamic University –
went to classes. According to
sources of the emergency committee, 90 percent of the subjects of the university
curricula was covered and teachers and rooms for teaching these subjects were
provided.
(d)
The Violation of the Right to
Work
The
internal siege imposed on Palestinian cities and villages in the Gaza Strip also
obstructed the regular access of more than 50,000 Palestinian employees from the
southern area of the Gaza Strip to their work places in institutions of the
Palestinian National Authority and non-governmental organizations in Gaza City
and the northern area of the Gaza Strip. This
was a consequence of closing Salah El-Din Street and branch and bypass roads
(November 20-November 23, 2000). When
the branch road to the east of Kfar Darom settlement was reopened daily for
limited hours, 10:00-12:00 and 16:00-18:00 local time, employees from the
southern area could not go to their work places in Gaza City at the regular
hours due to the limited time period in which the roads were open.
These employees usually start their work at 8:00 in the morning and
conclude it at 14:30 or 15:00. Under
such limited periods of time for opening the mentioned road, they could not
reach their work places before 12:00, and they were forced to leave work earlier
in order to be able to go back home under the queue system on the mentioned
road. This resulted in obstructing
many services offered by ministries and non-governmental institutions.
Furthermore,
the internal siege imposed by the Israeli occupation forces on Palestinian
cities and villages obstructed the access of many Palestinian laborers to their
work places in the Gaza Strip, causing large financial losses to many factories
and companies.
Many
employees from the southern area working in Gaza City were forced to sleep in
their work places in ministries and non-governmental institutions in order to be
able to continue their work. Family
relationships and visits were disrupted, especially in the month of Ramadan when
Muslim families usually gather around break-fast tables.
Many students and employees from the southern area of the Gaza Strip were
forced to sleep in the houses of relatives and friends in Gaza City to avoid the
daily humiliations they faced while traveling on roads between the north and
south of the Gaza Strip.
In
another step to suffocate Palestinian citizens, on December 4, 2000, the Israeli
occupation forces closed Al-Shuhada (Netzarim) junction on Salah El-Din Street,
to the south of Gaza City. As a
result, the Gaza Strip was transformed into three almost isolated areas (the
north, the middle and the south). This
deprived Palestinian citizens from their right to free movement.
On that same day, a tank of the Israeli occupation forces was positioned
at the entrance of Khadija Bent Khowailed elementary school, to the north of Al-Shuhada
(Netzarim) junction, preventing the access of more than 800 pupils to their
school.
On
December 5, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces partially reopened Salah El-Din
Street (the main road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip) between Al-Matahen
junction leading to Gush Qatif settlement block and the junction leading to the
town of Deir El-Balah known as Al-Heker. The
road is reopened daily from 9:00 until 16:00 local time.
This road has a heavy presence of the Israeli occupation forces
reinforced with tanks and armored vehicles.
Transportation on the road is rare because settlers of settlements
adjacent to the road go out to the road and throw stones at Palestinian vehicles
under the watching eyes and silence of the Israeli occupation forces.
Actions of this sort threaten the lives and safety of Palestinian
citizens. Consequently, Palestinian
drivers avoid traveling this road because they fear attacks by settlers.
The eastern branch road between Khan Yunis and the middle area of the
Gaza Strip witnesses traffic jams because of roadblocks established by the
Israeli occupation forces on the road. Palestinian
citizens on both sides of the road are forced to walk more than 3 kilometers to
reach their houses and work places. Israeli
occupation forces positioned at roadblocks allow the passage of Palestinian cars
according to their moods. They
often stop Palestinian vehicles for long periods, during which hundreds of these
vehicles are forced to stop in queues along the road.
Then, these forces allow the passage of a limited number of cars before
very quickly once again stopping movement and again obstructing and disturbing
the movement of Palestinian citizens and transportation on the road.
While
the suffering of Palestinian civilians under internal sieges and tough
restrictions on free movement increases, living conditions increasingly
deteriorate and economic, social and cultural rights are violated, settlers in
their vehicles are able to move freely on the main and branch roads in the Gaza
Strip under the escort of the Israeli occupation forces.
Everyone knows exactly the role settlers play in hurting and attacking
Palestinian citizens and their property, by blocking roads, and terrifying
Palestinian civilians. This is an
additional threat to the lives and safety of Palestinian civilians.
On December 7 and 8, 2000, settlers reached Salah El-Din Street and threw
stones at Palestinian vehicles while the Israeli occupation forces looked on
passively. Consequently,
Palestinian vehicles were forced to travel on the eastern branch road, on which
roadblocks of the Israeli occupation forces are established, obstructing the
movement of Palestinian citizens.
These
measures taken by the Israeli occupation forces practically divided the Gaza
Strip into two main parts, the northern part, from Beit Hanoun in the north to
Kfar Darom settlement near Deir El-Balah, and the southern part, from Deir El-Balah
to the city of Rafah in the south. This
separation is the most serious one since the Israeli occupation forces occupied
the Gaza Strip 33 years ago.
On
December 11, 2000, the Israeli occupation forces closed Salah El-Din Street (the
main road between the north and south of the Gaza Strip) and reopened it on the
following day. On December 13, the Israeli occupation forces closed the main
western road between Rafah and Khan Yunis with cement blocks and a tank of these
forces was positioned on the road near Morag settlement.
Consequently, the Israeli occupation forces isolated the cities of Rafah
and Khan Yunis from each other. Later,
these forces reopened the mentioned road, but they kept cement blocks on it.
Conclusion
The
Israeli occupation forces have continued to impose a total siege on the occupied
Palestinian territories. In
addition, these forces have been imposing an internal siege on Palestinian
cities and villages. Under the siege, the suffering of the Palestinian people is
continuous. Living conditions in the occupied Palestinian territories
have deteriorated at all levels and economic, social and cultural rights
continue to be violated.
PCHR
disapproves of the silence of the international community before the continued
blatant Israeli challenge to international humanitarian law and the continued
aggression launched by the Israeli occupation authorities against the
Palestinian people.
PCHR
expresses its disappointment and growing frustration with the silence of the
international community towards blatant Israeli violations of international
humanitarian law and continued military, economic and political aggression
launched by the Israeli occupation forces against the Palestinian people.
PCHR reiterates its call upon the international community to immediately
intervene to put an end to the violations of human rights in the occupied
Palestinian territories by the Israeli occupation forces and to ensure
Israel’s compliance with international conventions through:
(a)
Pressing Israel to lift the siege imposed on the Gaza Strip and to stop
its aggression against the Palestinian people and their property.
(b)
Providing immediate medical and humanitarian assistance for the
Palestinian people, whose living conditions have been increasingly deteriorating
under the siege.
(c)
Activating mechanisms of immediate intervention by the UN and its
agencies, and the ICRC, to ensure the access of medical assistance and food
assistance to the Palestinian people in the occupied Palestinian territories
under siege.
(d)
Obligating Israel to respect international conventions and to comply with
relevant UN Resolutions, especially 242 and 338, which call for a complete
Israeli withdrawal from the Palestinian territories occupied in 1967.
(e)
Taking effective steps by the EU to comply with Article 2 of the
Euro-Israel Association Agreement which provides that Israel must respect human
rights.
“End”
Annex (1)
Closures of crossings since Al-Aqsa Intifada began
|
The Crossing |
Closure |
Partial Reopening |
|
Al-Mentar
(Karni) |
Closed
on September 29, 2000 Re-closed
on October 8, 2000 Re-closed
on November 14, 2000 |
On
October 2, 2000 On
October 10, 2000 On
November 19, 2000 |
|
Sofa |
October
8, 2000 – now |
|
|
Erez |
October
8, 2000 – now |
Partially
reopened on November 14, 2000, allowing the entry of a limited number of
Palestinian laborers |
|
Rafah
Border Crossing |
Closed
on October 8, 2000 Re-closed
on October 12, 2000 Re-closed
on October 16, 2000 Re-closed
on November 8, 2000 Re-closed
on December 11, 2000, from 10:00 to 12:00 local time |
On
Oct. 10 with reduced staff On
October 15, 2000 On
October 19, 2000 On
November 20, 2000, and was re-closed on the same day; partially
reopened on November 28, 2000 |
|
Gaza
International Airport |
Closed
on October 8, 2000 Re-closed
on October 29, 2000 Re-closed
on November 8, 2000 |
On
October 15, 2000 On
November 6, 2000 Partially
reopened on December 1, 2000 |